Wise Guys Pizza Buffalo

Zak M 3 months ago

The service is always friendly. It’s a family owned place, true to the Buffalo roots. Great homemade blue cheese and the slices are huge. I work around the corner and they’ve always treated me well, never a bad experience. Prices are reasonable and I’ll be honest- they deserve your business.

kelly B 4 months ago

Pizza was excellent! Wings were huge, the honey garlic and logan berry wings were delicious. The blue cheese was delicious, and I liked that they gave a lot of celery. Good family owned pizzeria! First time ordering from there and we live around the corner from them. Glad we tried it.

Rebecca Piskor 5 months ago

Food is always delicious! Great portions for great prices. This is the 15 boneless wing lunch special which also comes with a can of pop, although I was surprised to find a two liter when it was delivered! Definitely join the loyalty program for reward points and birthday specials. I only put atmosphere as 4 because I've only gotten delivery from them so.

Jett Y Edited 4 months ago

Dear Wise Guys Pizza, first - please know that I'm leaving this review because I believe y'all could be one of the best pizza joints in Buffalo and I really want y'all to be successful. Today was my first time ordering from U. Unfortunately, I went from GLAD to SAD pretty quickly. I ordered a cheeseburger sub with extra cheese. When I took it out of the wrapper I was absolutely thrilled at the presentation. (Please see attached pics). I was so excited to finally find a place where the food looked just like the owners pics! The meat, cheese and lettuce was pouring out from every side of the fresh Costanzo roll! (Not barely there ingredients where all U can see is the roll like at most pizza & sub shops nowadays!) But then came the sad part. Unfortunately the burgers were very thin and, quite frankly- tasted like burnt cardboard. They were the driest pieces of meat I've ever tasted. My first thought was; I wonder if the owner eats this and thinks it tastes good? Like I mentioned, this is my first time ordering from Wise Guys. I will give it one more shot and order something different and see how that goes. I will leave another review when I do. Meanwhile, if the owner reads th

Peter G 7 months ago

Spectacular pizza so greasy so cheesy sweet sause outstanding wings to so big and juicy my mind was blown definitely would come back not much for sitting area but great hospitality